secularbuddhism.org.nz

This-Life Practice

an independent NZ guide to secular Buddhism and everyday practice

Ideas · · 4 min read

Facing tradition and a secular approach

How a secular reading of Buddhism sits alongside the inherited schools, where the real disagreements lie, and why neither side needs to win.

There is a real divide between traditional Buddhism and secular readings of it, and it is not helped by pretending otherwise. Traditional schools generally hold that rebirth and karma are part of how things are, and that the goal of practice is liberation from the round of rebirth. Secular readings generally set those claims aside and look for the point of practice within a single life. These are different pictures, and people on each side have thought hard about them.

This note tries to describe the divide fairly, and to suggest how someone drawn to a secular approach can live with it without contempt for the traditions it grew out of.

The traditions, briefly

Buddhism has never been one thing. Over two and a half thousand years it has spread across Asia and taken many forms. Three broad families are usually named:

  • Theravada, the "teaching of the elders", found today mainly in Sri Lanka, Myanmar, Thailand, Laos and Cambodia. It preserves the Pali Canon as its scripture.
  • Mahayana, the "great vehicle", which includes the Zen (Chan), Pure Land and other schools of China, Korea, Japan and Vietnam, and adds a large body of later scriptures.
  • Vajrayana, often grouped with Mahayana, associated especially with Tibet and the Himalayan region, with its own tantric practices and texts.

Each of these is itself a family of lineages, with monastic and lay communities, local customs, and centuries of scholarship. New Zealand has temples and centres from all three, serving both migrant communities and people who came to Buddhism as adults.

A secular approach is much newer. It took shape largely in English-speaking countries over the last few decades, among people who were mostly not raised Buddhist. That history matters. Secular Buddhists are guests in a very old house, and it pays to remember it.

Where the divide really lies

It is tempting to frame the disagreement as "science versus superstition". That is unfair to both sides and misses where the serious arguments are.

Rebirth and karma

The early texts speak of rebirth often and without embarrassment. Karma, in those texts, is above all about intention: what we choose to do shapes what we become. Traditional teachers argue that removing rebirth changes the stakes of the whole path: without many lives, the deep motivation for practice is lost. Secular practitioners reply that this-life suffering is reason enough, and that the intention-centred view of karma is meaningful within one life.

Both positions can be held thoughtfully. Neither can be proved by quoting the other side's favourite passages.

Authority

Traditions carry authority through lineage, teachers, commentaries and monastic discipline. A secular reading tends to place more weight on the individual's own testing of teachings. Traditional critics point out, fairly, that "test it yourself" can turn into "keep what I like". Secular practitioners answer that every tradition has adapted the teachings to new cultures, and that adaptation done honestly is part of the inheritance.

What the goal is

For traditional schools, the goal is awakening understood as a decisive transformation, often expressed as the end of rebirth. Secular readings tend to describe the goal more modestly, as a life less driven by craving and reactivity, lived with more care. There is a separate note on what people mean by awakening.

What the early texts suggest about holding teachings

One image from the early discourses is useful to both sides. The Buddha compares his teaching to a raft: someone crossing a flood builds a raft from branches and grass and crosses safely. On the far shore, it would be foolish to hoist the raft on their head and carry it about. The teaching, he says, is "for crossing over, not for holding on" (MN 22 on SuttaCentral).

The same discourse also warns against grasping teachings wrongly, like catching a snake by the tail. It is not saying that teachings do not matter. It is saying that they are tools for a purpose, and that clinging to them, even correct ones, becomes its own problem.

A secular reader can take this as permission to hold the traditional cosmology lightly. A traditional reader can take it as a warning against turning secular opinions into a new dogma. Both readings are available, and both are worth hearing.

Living with the divide

A few habits help.

Describe traditions accurately. Before criticising a traditional view, it is worth being able to state it in a way its holders would recognise. A good test is whether a Theravada monk or a Tibetan lama would say, "Yes, that is what we believe, though we would put it differently."

Separate the questions. Whether rebirth happens is one question. Whether you can practise usefully without settling it is another. Many people answer the second "yes" while leaving the first open.

Remember who kept the texts. The discourses that secular practitioners read in English exist because monastics memorised, copied and studied them for more than two thousand years. That is a debt, not a footnote.

Expect to be changed. Many people who start with a firmly secular view find their reading of the texts shifting over the years, sometimes towards tradition, sometimes further away. That movement is a sign of honest study, not a failure of nerve.

No points to score

There is a temptation, in online argument especially, to treat this as a contest. It is more useful to see the divide as two serious answers to the same question: what to do with an ancient, rich and strange body of teaching in the world we actually live in.

For a careful, non-partisan overview of what scholars can and cannot say about the historical Buddha and his teaching, the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy entry on the Buddha is well worth reading, alongside the texts themselves.